The Listless List: 5 Worst Anime of Winter 2018

With the Winter 2018 Anime season coming to a close, and having already gone through my personal favourites, it’s time I picked out the shows I considered to be the most disappointing, underwhelming or just plain difficult to watch.

As always these are just my own personal picks, and there’s a high chance you may have enjoyed some of these and have had completely different picks from mine.

Also, my picks for this list may not necessarily be the worst shows of the lot, since there’s a lot of shows I haven’t watched enough of to fully include, such as Death March, which would be an obvious choice for this list. Furthermore, a lot of these choices are based on how disappointing and underwhelming they ended up being, as opposed to flat out “bad”. So… Yeah!

db9ad334b9eeb1c826b3160ad8133c7724211a77_hq

5. Junji Ito Collection

As a huge fan of Junji Ito’s original work, and as someone who really enjoys twisted horror stories in general, I was really looking forward to this adaptation. When I heard that Studio Deen was going to animate a collection of various short horror Manga created by Junji Ito, I was freaking hyped.

But unfortunately, it seems that this one just wasn’t meant to be.

While the stories themselves are some of the best choices they could have made, and while this collection adapts them more or less panel for panel, the amazing presentation of the original Manga is completely lost, buried underneath a lazily put together exterior of horrible artwork and poor directing.

I’m not normally one to have a strong dislike for something solely based on its visual presentation, but much of the charm and atmosphere of the original work is almost a direct result of Ito’s incredible artwork and panel flow, both of which Studio Deen seem to have unfortunately failed to bring into this adaptation.

The stories themselves are fine, but the atmosphere and sheer sense of terror that are a vital component of each of them are both completely gone, and makes this whole adaptation feel flat as a result.

If you’ve never experienced Ito’s short stories, I’d still recommend maybe giving this one a go, but if you’re already a big fan of the original Manga, I’d suggest giving this one a miss.

Maybe next time…

4. Pop Team Epic

Given a lot of the positive response I’d seen to this show, and considering all the memes it seems to have spawned since it started airing, I expected so much more from Pop Team Epic. I expected something that was genuinely funny, and full of great, meme worthy content.

Instead, all I was given was unfunny jokes in the form of constant referential comedy that just doesn’t appeal to me at all, and it’s made even worse by the aesthetic, which I’m also not the biggest fan of.

I can definitely see the appeal of this show, and I understand why it’s as popular as it and why everyone loves it so much, but Pop Team Epic has been a huge miss for me, and just doesn’t appeal to me on any level.

I guess Gintama is still the best referential comedy in Anime. By a freaking mile.

3. Yuru Camp△

It seems that every single season, one of these cute girls doing cute things shows some how ends up on this list, and it seems Yuru Camp is the unfortunate victim of this season.

I’m not a big fan of these kinds of shows to begin with, but I can normally find something to latch on to, even if there’s very little that appeals to me, but there’s just nothing for me in Yuru Camp.

I’m not all that fond of camping, given some pretty awful and boring experiences I had with camping growing up, and that combined with the fact that nothing all that interesting happens in this show at all, just makes it very boring for me.

It’s a show about cute girls going cute camping. I can see why this would appeal to many, but nah. It’s not my thing. Sorry.

2. Violet Evergarden

Ohhhh boy! I’m going to get absolutely crucified for this one. Heck, I was originally going to put it at the top of this list, until I remembered that a certain other show came out this season, and it just managed to overtake this one ever so slightly.

Look, Violet Evergarden is probably great. I have no doubt in my mind, that this show is as great as people are saying it is. But I just don’t get it. It doesn’t click with me. I found it incredibly difficult to watch and I really don’t care about anything in this show outside of the pretty good visuals and directing, both of which are also unfortunately very outside of my personal preferences.

It’s the same old story with me and Kyoto Animation shows. They seem interesting, only to devolve into something far less interesting and pretty cliche fairly quickly. Nothing about this story is all that different from the usual KyoAni fare, outside of its setting, which honestly isn’t all that developed or interesting enough for me to get invested.

And when the show does try to be about something that would normally interest me, a war story, it just doesn’t work as one. At all. It’d be better of continuing to be the other thing it is: a feelsy, emotional, tear jerker about Violet Evergarden, the girl with no emotions.

I could ramble about how I don’t care for Violet or her personality in the slightest, or how the story itself is nothing all that special, but I won’t because I don’t want to come across as a snarky asshole who feels the need to go all “analytical diatribe” on those who love this show as much as they do.

I feel bad that I couldn’t “get” Violet Evergarden, and the main reason this show is as high on this list as it is, is because of how disappointing it wound up being for me, as opposed to it being a “bad” show. Perhaps I’ll give it another spin in the future, but for now this show just isn’t doing it for me. At all.

Please don’t kill me.

1. Fate/Extra: Last Encore

I don’t like Fate. I just dislike almost everything about this franchise.

So it’s no surprise that, once again, a Fate series has been given the top spot on this list.

Whatever else I could say would just be me rehashing what I said about Apocrypha some time ago. So I won’t bother repeating myself.

I just don’t care about Fate. This show has done little to change my mind.

Sorry. That’s super dismissive and pretty bad of me, but I just don’t have much else to say that’s new.

Maybe the next one will win me over.

f9c0a-tanakakunheader

Share your worst picks:

What were your least favourite shows from the Winter 2018 Anime Season? Feel free to share yours in the comments!

 

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “The Listless List: 5 Worst Anime of Winter 2018

  1. Hmm, well I haven’t seen all of these so partial no comment for most of it.

    As for Junji, yeah that wasn’t great but I did enjoy it still so I wouldn’t say it was the worst for me at least. I’ll HM it. Pop Team Epic *bleh* (excuse me I threw up a little bit there) I absolutely hate on the other hand so…

    Yuru Camp and Evergarden are your hottest takes yet though. I haven’t seen either but the internet really loves them. I think I would enjoy Evergarden a lot but Yuru Camp I could take or leave. Lastly, Fate is an obligatory watch for me so who knows?

    As for my actual worst of the season I would give that to *drum roll*

    1. Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens – a lot of folks love this but I feel like it is just somebody trying really hard to do a Durara style story poorly. It’s like a 6/10 for me, not bad but…
    2. The ending specifically to Magus’ Bride – Again, more on that later.
    3. Overlord S2 – Haven’t finished it but my goodness… what I have seen has been absolutely dreadful outside of a few very select moments.
    4. Pop Team Epic – See above

    HM: Junji Ito but not because I didn’t enjoy but because it is lackluster for a “horror” show. Like I said.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Junji Ito Collection seemed to disappoint a lot of people. Pop Team Epic didn’t seem like my kind of show, and I’m glad to know I’m not the only one who doesn’t adore the series or find it hilarious.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. It’s really unfortunate, because it could have been something amazing if it just presented itself better, but I guess it just wasn’t meant to be…

      Nice to see I ain’t alone on my thoughts on Pop Team Epic, given I’ve seen nothing but praise for it literally everywhere.

      Thanks for reading!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I can understand why you wouldn’t like YuruCamp – heck, the cute factor didn’t discriminate this season, and that’s why I had to put YuruCamp in my lineup for balance. It wasn’t completely bad on my end, but it did end up being one of the worst I saw through to the end. The other was strangely Ancient Magus’ Bride. I can’t talk about episode 24 because I haven’t watched it yet, but aside from that choppy pacing from the first cour carrying over, the subtler problems of the show (such as quite a few characters that were introduced in the first cour lacking characterisation beyond that) really come to the fore when it starts lengthening its story arcs.

    I did skip on all the mostly-panned shows this season though, so there’s a plus. On the other hand, I know a lot of people will complain that I dropped Yorimoi (A Place Further Than the Universe), but then again, my relationship with that show was… complicated.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wouldn’t even say that Yuru Camp is “bad” it’s just… Not my thing, really and didn’t “click” with me, which is the worst thing about it.

      And that’s an interesting take on Magus Bride. I’ve heard almost universal praise for the series, so to hear you’ve had issues with it is pretty interesting. I wonder how I’ll feel about it myself… I’ll get around to it at some point I guess!

      You DROPPED Yorimoi?! Wow! I’m very curious as to why. Do tell! 😛

      Like

      1. YuruCamp isn’t snoozeworthy, but it’s not my thing either. I’m not really into CGDCT or camping, and yet I made it through the show having enjoyed the trips I had with the Outclub.

        Actually, if you read takes on the final episode or both cours of Magus’ Bride, you’ll see some of the opinions echo mine (the praise is for the first cour, mostly). Now that I’ve seen it, I think it’s the final episode in particular that ticks off a lot of people.

        At first, I dropped Yorimoi because I found Shirase’s smile creepy and couldn’t see the catlike qualities to it, but the more I thought about dropping Yorimoi, the more I wondered why I didn’t take big risks like those girls. In the end, I made a trip to a shopping centre (a big one quite a distance away) without much planning and decided not taking risks is fine too, but the existential crisis I ended up associating with the show was enough to never make me touch it again.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I do understand the Violet Evergarden part, though I don’t actually despise it. It’s quite watchable (great OSTs too), but it isn’t something I’d finish if not for the fact that I’m reviewing it. I tend to get tired of cliches easily as well – especially the feelsy kind.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Don’t feel bad about not liking Violet Evergarden.

    To my mind, while it’s pretty to look at, it’s actually largely devoid of the imaginative animation that is the trademark of Kyoto Animation (think Hyouka). More importantly, I abhor when a show is so obviously trying to manipulate its audience through cheap storytelling tricks, and this series has just been one such manipulation after another: the dying soldier sending a letter to his girl back home; the father unable to stop mourning his dead daughter; the little girl whose mother is slowly dying in front of her.

    I’m surprised there wasn’t an episode of someone watching their beloved puppy get slaughtered.

    And through it all, Jesus Evergarden saves the day!

    I acknowledge that there are people who like having their emotions toyed with so blatantly, but there’s certainly no shame in it if that doesn’t include you. It certainly doesn’t include me. Every fiber of my being rebels at this series and the people responsible for inflicting it upon the world!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s